Childhood,
Adolescence and University
Introduction
This is an
interesting autobiography. It tells of a simple young boy who came from an
intelligent family in a small village in South Africa, who came to be a physician
and then through sheer energy, intellectual curiosity and the fortunes of life,
became a cardiologist, carved his way through research and by the time he
turned 32 was a Departmental head in a teaching hospital.
He migrated to
Israel, set up a leading department of Cardiology, trained generations of
physicians and departmental heads of Cardiology, placed Israeli Cardiology on
the World map, and cared for simple people, Judges, Cabinet Ministers, Prime
Ministers and Presidents.
How did the good Lord
create this pathway?
Childhood
The Gotsman family
hailed from Galicia. The family spread out from Krakow from a small village
called Podgorze and radiated centrifugally with our branch migrating northwards
to Minsk. Grandfather Jacob was an expert carpenter. The Tsarist Russian
government mobilized the Jews to the army and to avoid this prolonged draft
decided to immigrate with his wife to England. He arrived in Newcastle, the
closest English port and soon found work in the docks working in the local
shipyard. He lived in Sunderland where
there was a large immigrant Jewish population and he felt at home. His first goal was to learn English and I
inherited his large library of leather bound novels with gold painting to
preserve the books from dust. He was successful and he spoke English without an
accent. The Union Castle Line had a
large repair dock yard in Cape Town and he was so successful that they
persuaded him to move to Cape Town in South Africa. The family moved again to another new country
and transculture and lived in the immigrant Jewish neighborhood in Roland
Street immediately adjacent to the new local synagogue. Jacob prospered, built
a specialist work shop at home and he made exquisite and complex productions of
furniture with all the local wood and also built the arks for the local
synagogues.
He had 5
children. Fanny the eldest married Mr.
Stone and returned to England, and raised a large family. Samuel was killed in
action against the Germans in Southwest Africa during the First World War, Israel
became the manager of a large brewery, Abraham was a school teacher and later
the principal of the primary school in Krugersdorp and my father, the youngest, was sent to
university to learn physics and land surveying.
He was highly intelligent and loved teaching and continued to teach at
the University of Cape Town; but during the depression of 1932, the staff of
the university was reduced and he found himself unemployed He joined his brother Abraham in Krugersdorp
and taught at the technical college in Johannesburg. There he met my mother- Ada Kab (Kobrowitzky). She was one of 6 children. Her mother had died in 1921 after the nationwide
influenza epidemic which devastated the country. She was the first person, together with her
new born baby who was interred at the new cemetery in Krugersdorp.
Krugersdorp, then,
was a large suburb on the western side of Johannesburg. It had rich gold
deposits and was the centre of the gold rush in the 1880's. It became a thriving
gold mining town which had exploded with the influx of the new fortune seekers.
Gold was plentiful, money flowed and work was abundant. It was also the major
market town for the surrounding farming district. My maternal grandfather was an expert leather
worker and repaired saddles and reins and other leather items on the horses and
carts of the farmers, traders and travelling merchants. He had plenty of work. The family lived and
worked next to the central market in the town centre. When the motor car
arrived, and the horses, carts and wagons disappeared he turned his hand to
cobbling and boot making. This grew into a small factory to make specialized boots
for the miners. I can remember watching
him at work with gnarled hands and a protective apron. Twice a week we
travelled to Rustenberg about 50 Kms. distance to fetch the leather from the
tanneries for the day's work. We would
leave at 5 a.m. in the morning in his old model T Ford car. The leather had a strong, unpleasant odor but
he lived from hand to mouth and had to buy everything for cash. The family lived
in a house adjacent to the work shop, but my strongest memory was the outdoor
"spooky" toilet and I was terrified of the snakes at night. He had remarried a pleasant lady with 2
children. The family had a strong Jewish
tradition. They spoke Yiddish at home and although he read English, wrote
everything in Yiddish.
My mother was
introduced to my father and after a short "shiduch" they were
married.
The great depression
passed and South Africa emerged unscathed. My father returned to the University
of Cape Town as a senior research fellow in the department of physics. Professor
Ogg, the departmental chief, had been an expert in crystallography and had
shifted into geo-magnetism. He
established a new research and service unit in the department. The magnetic north varies by 1 to 2 degrees
every week and this is essential for calibrating compasses in ships at
sea. A small deviation can change the
trajectory of a ship and allow it to deviate many kilometers in the course of
the day. My newly married father rented
a house and moved to Muizenburg, or more commonly nicknamed as
"Jewsenberg". This eclectic beach-side suburb is located on the Western
side of False Bay and is bathed by the warm Mozambique current. It has long shallow beaches, the ocean is warm
and it is protected from the prevailing cold winds. Mountains rising to the west keep out the
cold, wintery Northwest winds. It is an
ideal location to live and it seemed that the entire Jewish population of South
Africa would arrive for the summer holidays.
They basked in the sun and lived on the beach.
I was born in the Mowbray maternity home, a
suburb of Cape Town on the 29th of August 1935, in the early hours of the
morning. This was the main maternity
hospital in the area, and I was delivered by one of the midwives. I was a big
fat baby and my proud parents took me to Muizenberg. It was a very pleasant early childhood, and
my mother had many friends of her own age who had very young children. There was a long promenade along the beach where
we would spend the mornings in the sun and we would end every walk with a
sundae at the local ice cream parlor. We
lived a happy, carefree life. Our house
was located near the False Bay railway station and I can remember waiting for
my father every afternoon as he arrived on the 5:30 electric train. Later, the
Krugersdorp branch of our family bought a holiday cottage near the water and
would spend their summers in Muizenberg. This magnificent vibrant community
gradually dwindled as the younger members left for the larger towns or migrated
to Australia or Canada. It is now a faded beauty and a reminder of how a
vibrant Jewish town can lose some of its charm over time.
The outbreak of World
War II brought major changes to Cape Town.
Both the German and Allied fleets realized the importance of the sea
route between Europe and the Far East. The magnetic observatory was a strategic
institution to guide the Allied ships and was moved to a country location at
Hermanus. It also removed the influence of the radiation from the exposed wires
of the local suburban, electric trains.
Hermanus is located
at the southern tip of South Africa. The
cold Benguella current and the warm Mozambique currents meet at Cape Agulhas,
the southernmost point of the African continent. It had a rich history. The Portuguese and Dutch sailors had found a
route to the Far East around the southern tip of South Africa and a halfway
station to provide fresh water, vegetables, and meat for passing ships
travelling to and from Asia. Cape Town
was the obvious major port of call and was a place to repair ships, wait for
other ships in the fleet and allow sick mariners to recover. The Dutch East India Company built a small
colony for their ships traveling from Holland to Batavia (Indonesia). The Cape became an outstation of the Dutch
East India Company's eastern empire, based in Batavia in Java. During the
Napoleonic Wars, they were displaced by the British.
The European ships to
the Asian colonies had to circumnavigate the southern tip of Africa and because
of the interaction between the two currents it was often windy and misty with
heavy fogs. The Agulhas bank is shallow and extends for 80 km from the coast,
which explains the propensity for ships to run aground on the rocks. History is
rich in ships which had gone aground off Cape Agulhas. It was the graveyard of many ships, and the
survivors explored the neighboring area.
They found a quiet bay where they settled and called it Hermanus
Petrusfontein. It has a Mediterranean climate but the north and southward movements
of the sun produce two divergent winds.
The southeast trade winds in the summer and the northwest anti- trades
in the winter produced warm dry summers and cool wet winters. The town has the finest and purest air in the
country and became a magnet for holiday makers.
Hermanus is a
beautiful village. It is located between
the mountains and the sea. The mountains are covered with a unique "fynbos"
scrub and heath and unusual indigenous flowers.
Spring brings a flourish of flora and the multicolored fields cover the
land. It has a very big golf club with
many international tournaments and on Sunday mornings I would earn 6 pence for
caddying on the golf course. On Monday,
I would spend my earnings and buy the weekly picture books from England which
had arrived on the Friday mail steamer.
I loved the "Champion and Triumph" with stories of Rockfist
Rogan, the spitfire pilot and his exploits and Gusty Gale the intelligent boy
at the grammar school. I also read the monthly Sexton Blake detective
stories. Often I ran a credit at the
local paper shop. "Picture Post"
was the popular English weekly and brought vivid black and white pictures of
the Second World War in England and Europe.
The coast is rocky
with strong tides and currents and we would swim in the little coves or on the
beach to the west of the town. They were
permeated with the the smell of iodine from the seaweed and the salt winds from
the sea. The climate was very moderate
and temperate with warm summers and without real cold winters. There were well worn paths along the coast
and at the foothills of the mountains and I would spend hours walking and
exploring the hinterland.
We arrived in
Hermanus on the first of January 1940.
We lived in the local Windsor Hotel on the rocky sea front for a few
months. We then rented two different houses until finally we bought our own
home with plenty of living space.
My father worked at
the newly built Magnetic Observatory. It was built to the west of the town in
distant scrub covered fields. It had 4 buildings: an office block, a building
with instruments for calibration and precise localization, and another block
which housed other instruments to monitor the daily variable motions of the
North Pole. A 4th block had geodetic instruments for measuring earthquake
vibrations and outside in the grass covered fields a variety of meteorological
devices. I grew up close to my father and we would spend Sundays taking down
and changing the recordings and making the daily calculations. The changes were
recorded as graphs on photographic paper. This needed developing and drying
like long reels of cine film. He would then measure the changes and use a large
desktop calculator to measure the statistical fluctuations. Later this was broadcast
to the ships. It was my interesting
introduction to scientific methods and calculations and statistics.
I was 4 years old
when we arrived and I started school immediately in the 1st grade. It was a
modern E shaped building covered with hewn stone, large windows to let in the
light and always cleanly painted. The school had separate English and Afrikaans
speaking classes. The English section
was very small and we had 3 grades together in one classroom with a total of
about 20 pupils. Miss Earp Jones, the
daughter of the local Archbishop, was an excellent teacher, and I made rapid
progress particularly when I learned together with the 2 more senior classes in
same class room.
The remainder of my
primary schooling was smooth and this continued into high school. The English and Afrikaans sections merged and
the classes became smaller and smaller. Although
English was our home language I soon became fluent in Afrikaans. We were the
first matriculating class in the school. The class comprised only 4 pupils so
that we received personal individualized teaching.
Memories of the
teachers and of school are still etched sharply in my memory. Mrs. Morkel taught me how to use my hands.
She was a practical handwork and modeling teacher. Mr. van Dyke taught me
carpentry and we had unusual Friday mornings classes where we learned how to
dismantle and reassemble a telephone,
radio and even a motor car engine. We
traveled to all the surrounding factories and learned about paper production,
printing, brick and furniture making, jam production, wine making and other
common procedures. This broadened my
general knowledge and inculcated in me a spirit of enquiry to understand how
everything worked. This has lasted until today. Mr Wessels was the science
master and he inculcated a love of science. Miss Ross was a flamboyant red head
and improved my English, while the school principle, Mr Jones taught Chemistry
and Mathematics. One recalls very strong impressions of childhood that have not
faded. This is probably the greatest "memory bump" that has survived.
I was a voracious
reader. I read all the books and
children's novels in the school library and then found a rich collection in the
Town library. My English was honed by constant practice. G.A. Henty was my favorite
author.
My daily schedule was
very simple: School in the morning and early afternoon with cheder in the late
afternoon followed by an hour or two of sport.
Synagogue was in the evening, supper and then two or three hours of
homework and learning.
The final combination
of subjects chosen for the matriculation examination was a little unusual since
it was dictated by the needs of the other pupils. I took English and Afrikaans as a first
language and chemistry, geography, mathematics, and accounting. My father added Latin, Hebrew and a little German. I graduated as top student in the Province
(State). I was fascinated by Afrikaans
and had an excellent teacher in Mr. Joubert.
He taught me the elements of etymology, the history and development of
the language from the other Aryan languages, German, Dutch and Flemish. We studied many texts in each of these
languages and this left me with a love of literature and language. Mr. Joubert was a tall, thin and bald and
full of enthusiasm. He also taught me
geography for many years and left me with a legacy of understanding pictures,
maps and the world. My father
supplemented my library with books on cartography and physical and economic
geography. I learnt how to sketch and illustrate all the difficult points. I
had never heard of semiotics but this was the basis of my visual approach to
knowledge. Today I am an expert in using the blackboard for teaching to explain
and simplify the most complex concepts.
School was a happy
experience. My father was my friend, tutor and mentor. Our house had a large enclosed veranda which
I used as a study and we would sit down in the evening to revise school lessons
and study related texts. He loved books
and I had a large library of university text books on the different school subjects.
I was very successful
at school and was top student in the country in the Junior Certificate
Examination (10th grade) and second top student in the Matriculation
Examination (12th grade).
Life was free and
easy. The village was small and everything within walking distance. There were
no pressures of time and my good performance at school was achieved by regular
daily learning. My understanding was good, the ideas and concepts were clear
and my memory sharpened by constant repetition.
The radio was our main
source of information from the outside world. We had a large Marconi receiver
and we erected a special antenna to receive the BBC broadcasts from London. Reception
was possible in the evenings only and we would listen carefully to the 8PM
news. I followed the progress of the Second World War carefully and the Cape Times,
the main English newspaper from Cape Town, also arrived in the late afternoon
and carried daily maps of the progress of the war in North Africa, Italy and
Europe after the D-day landings. We were not aware of the extent of the
holocaust, but I have vivid memories of the progress on the fighting on the
different fronts.
I was not a great
sportsman but played tennis, was a lock forward
in the rugby team, ran the 440 yards in athletics, but was an excellent wicket
keeper in cricket, with the safest hands in
the town. Pam Hands, an ex Springbok,
international player was an enthusiastic local cricket coach and he taught me
how to bat, keep wicket and even how to be an excellent spin bowler. I loved cricket and my father made sure that
I had my own bat, pads and wicket keeping gloves. All were expensive items on
our limited budget.
Hermanus was a big
fishing village and my mother would give me one shilling every day to buy fresh
fish from the fishermen who returned with their afternoon catch. I would walk down to the old harbor after
school. There was an inlet in the bay
between steep rocks which was protected from the tides and the winds. The
fishermen would go to sea in their small rowing boats which had a small fore
sail and they sought and followed the fish shoals in the bay. When they returned
they would lift the boats from the water physically, and then pull them onto
the slipway. The women would help to
remove the superficial scales and the innards of the fish. The fish came in all sizes and tastes and the
slipway had a strong fishy smell. Part of the catch was sold directly in the
harbor market; the rest was placed on ice and transported to neighboring market
towns. I became an expert on fish and had to identify the non-kosher strains.
The old harbor in Hermanus
There were many
Hermanus old families who had lived there for three or four generations and who
had played a prominent role in developing the town. I mixed freely with the
younger generation.
Apartheid was very
strong. The mullato (coloured) populations were segregated from the whites living
in their own villages of Mount Pleasant and Hawston and there were very few
blacks.
We had two family
physicians. Dr Cohen was an assimilated General practitioner from Germany who
had repeated his last three years of study at the University of Cape Town while
Dr. Taylor had retired from the Indian Medical Service and had studied in
Scotland. He gave me my first medical textbook: William Osler's Principles and
Practice of Medicine.
Transport was
difficult. We could not afford a motor
car and there was no railway line in Hermanus.
We would take the 10:30a.m. (charabank) bus to Bot River and catch the
12 p.m. train to Cape Town. The train had to pass over the Hottentots Holland mountain
pass and because of the steep climb the 60 Km ride took 4 hours. The train
crawled along the climb with the engine emitting thick clouds of black smoke: it
arrived at Cape Town at 4 p.m. The trip
took all day and the return trip was equally tiring. Later there was a direct bus to Cape Town but
I could never afford the 10 shilling fare.
When I went to university I would hitchhike home for the weekends.
Being Jewish was not
popular in the town, and my nickname was "Joodjie". I learned to box and wrestle for self defense
and once or twice a week I had to defend myself on the way home from school. The social life was hard and I had few
non-Jewish friends.
Hermanus had a
typical Jewish enclave. The families
were second generation Jews from Lithuania or Russia. The 15 families were either shopkeepers or
hotel owners. The town had a lovely
synagogue, built with gables in the Dutch style. We painted it once a year and
kept it clean and trim. Mr. Chaim Falkoff
was the local reverend: he taught the children, conducted the daily synagogue
services and acted as the local shochet (ritual slaughterer). He would
slaughter a sheep or cow once a week, sufficient for the needs of the community,
and on Thursdays would come to our house to kill one of our chickens for
Shabbat. For many years he tutored me
for an hour after school. I mastered the prayers, a little Hebrew and some Bible,
but his native language was Yiddish and mine was English. I missed out on a really thorough Jewish
education. The small community managed a daily minyan (quorum) for
prayers. I had a good voice and
although I really did not understand all the Hebrew could conduct the services.
The other Jewish children were sent to boarding schools in Cape Town so that my
sister and I were the only Jewish children at the local school. We tried to observe Shabbat and maintain a
modicum of kashrut. Joe Smith, the local
Jewish green grocer, would visit Cape Town on Wednesdays and bring kosher food,
cold meats, sausage and salted herring. My mother was friendly with the other Jewish
women, but my father had little in common with the other Jewish merchants or
hotelkeepers.
This is such a contrast to the education of
the children in the "Schtetl"
Baruch Goldstein, an elderly rabbi from Worcester, Massachusetts
described his childhood in Mlawa, a Polish town half way between Warsaw and the
German border. One quarter of the
population was Jewish and their activities were concentrated around the "shul
gasse". This had 3 synagogues
and an old and a new beit midrash. The
Jews belonged to all streams of religion and the younger generation
participated in different political youth groups. The religious learned in the yeshiva where
the emphasis was on mitzvot and prayers.
They spoke Yiddish and immersed themselves in Talmud. The older children were sent to more advanced
yeshivot in the well-known centers of Poland known for their excellence. The children wrote and spoke Hebrew and
understood Aramaic and the Talmudic discussions and systems of learning. They emerged as mature Jews. There were other
groups where Zionism and Hebrew were important and a third group who had been
influenced by general learning and the so called enlightenment and "haskalah".
This is in such
contrast to my own childhood and probably similar to most of the Jewish
children of my generation in South Africa. We were born Jewish and maintained
tradition. The importance and understanding of the simple mitzvot were
not emphasized and I barely understood the subjects in the Talmud and the
importance of Rashi and the other commentators. The Jewish community had grown away from the
Jewish education and religious environment.
It was a watered down existence which I discovered many years later when
I became a professor in Durban. I think
that my lack of understanding hastened my aliyah to Israel. I wanted to understand and use Hebrew and
understand my origins.
University of Cape Town – A New World
I was fortunate to be
awarded several scholarships to study at the University but it was a difficult
decision to choose a profession. I was very keen on mathematics but my father
vetoed this decision and we decided on actuarial science. This would be mathematics with a financial
future in the field of insurance.
Next to my mother's
little gift shop was a large lawyers office. Frikkie van Zyl was a young medical
student who was wooing the lawyer's secretary.
When the lawyer appeared he would take refuge and tea in my mother's
shop. He persuaded me to try medicine.
I had not studied
physics, zoology or botany at school and I used the long summer vacation to
prepare for the first year studies. When I arrived at the university I had
already prepared large portions of the syllabus.
The University of
Cape Town was located at a bend in the foothills of Table Mountain with a
spectacular panoramic view, over Table Bay and the Cape Flats but it was
isolated and 8 kilometers from Cape Town.
The University was
the premier university of South Africa with a long tradition of excellence and
scholarship. The medical school was established in 1930 and many of the
Professors had been recruited from England or Scotland. The aim was to produce
a well rounded general practitioner based on the Scottish Model. The medical
staff were great teachers rather than high powered research orientated
physician scientists.
The University was a
different experience and a culture shock. I was housed in University Hall. It was
built in 1946 as a temporary structure to house returning servicemen following
World War II, six blocks of single rooms facing an outside verandah. It was
nicknamed “Belsen” as it consisted of renovated Army Barracks
As a young 16 year
old boy from a country village I was catapulted into a new, unfamiliar life
style. I lived in the older University
dorms but within a Jewish micro ghetto.
We did not mix with the Afrikaans students and the English students did
not mix with us. The prejudices were
great and the English students controlled the sports fields. My greatest extra-curricular
activity was the debating society. I polished
my English and learned how to speak intelligently, spontaneously and fluently. The
Debating Society was the incubator for budding politicians and I entered
University politics. In my first year I also
joined an outreach program to coach underprivileged black students in science
and mathematics to prepare them for the University entrance exams.
The studies were easy
except for Botany. I went to the lecturer and explained my problems and she
gave me an extra hour of individual teaching every week. I would wake up at 5AM
and prepare the material and I had a wonderful time. I also did a course in
mathematics as I still had actuarial science at the back of my mind. I made
many friends and have continued to be in contact with them for the past 50
years.
We would daven
(pray) at the little, old Observatory Synagogue next to the medical school but
the old reverend had a bifid beard and always wore sharp pointed well polished
shoes but the cotton wool plugs in his
ears, and the elderly members of his congregation did not attract me. The
rundown shtieble (Synagogue) was not to my liking. It lacked "hadar" (beauty).
I would spend Shabbat with my student friends’ families in Oranjezicht, a
suburb of Cape Town. I would enjoy the
services in the large elegant and well kept Gardens Synagogue that had a cantor
and choir. It had decorum and cantorial music
and Rabbi Abrahams who had trained in London and spoke excellent English
explained the services and the background to the weekly Torah readings. The building had two large Moorish spires.
In my second year I
continued in the same residence and I walked to the adjacent medical school.
Anatomy and Physiology dealt with human beings: the subjects excited me and
really aroused my interest: I intensified my studies. We were divided into small groups for more
individual learning and I often acted as the leader of the group. We spent long hours in the, anatomy
laboratory and dissecting room and I was able to teach my fellow students the intricacies
of the structure of the human body. We
studied physiology texts together but Prof. Budtz Olsen was my favorite
physiology mentor. He would come with into
class with large multicolored pictures and diagrams to teach the different physiological
pathways. He would stand me in front of
the class and invite me to explain the diagrams. Today we would do this with power point
presentations, but his simple systems were just as effective. I came to understand physiology in depth and have
never lost my interest. Even in clinical
teaching I still use diagrams and drawings.
Pathology in the 3rd
year was more difficult. Prof. Thompson,
an explosive redhead from Glasgow, with bushy pointed eyebrows was an integrator,
but Golda Selzer and her young registrars were analysts and all the diseases
groups were neatly classified. We spent
much time in the post mortem room. I acted as leader to a group of students in
the museum which had the most unusual and extensive collection of pathological
specimens. We also devoted hours to examining
histological slides. We were a happy
coherent group who became close friends. Today this pathological material is freely
available on the Internet, stored in an electronic format and this permits easy
access and allows immediate retrieval and storage.
I moved to Medical
Residence that was housed in a much more elegant building and again we segregated
ourselves into our own tight Jewish micro environment but now we were joined by
the Catholic students. This residence was
formal with ties, jackets and gowns for dinner; it was modeled on the Oxbridge
system. The residence was part of the
Medical School- Hospital complex with a two minute walk to the Faculty teaching
facilities and a four-minute walk to Groote Schuur Hospital. We were a closely knit group of students and
after 60 years we are still in contact. To-day
I communicate through "skype" regularly and speak to one of my old
fellow students at least once a week.
Jill Waynik was my
first girlfriend, a relationship which developed within the medical school
class. We learned and prepared for the
examinations together.
The 4th year brought
another major change. The clinical years
introduced real clinical medicine and direct contact with the patients. We wore
long white coats, stethoscopes to listen to the heart and patella hammers for
eliciting tendon reflexes. We felt like real medical students and budding
doctors as we walked the wards and interacted with the patients. The teaching was very good. We met with a Medical tutor three times a
week and learned how to take a careful history and examine the patients. We were divided up into groups of 8
students. The tutor would select a
patient with a specific physical sign, such as a systolic murmur or
consolidation of the lung in pneumonia or an enlarged nodular liver. We would elicit the physical signs and then
discuss the differential diagnosis and pathophysiology. The tutors were senior physicians in private
practice who contributed their time to teaching the students. Less successful teachers were sent home. My favorite tutor was Robbie Slome with long
black hair and a sunburned face. He had
a wonderful manner of presentation, control of the class, spoke well and was able
to make the material simple and understandable.
He used diagrams to demonstrate points and we would come away
understanding and remembering the material.
He taught me the basics of cardiology which I have still preserved. Twice a week we met as a class of 120
students in a large lecture hall and had a demonstration of a patient with a
specific symptom such as shortness of breath or diarrhea. The two professors, Mersky and Eales had a well-organized
program to cover the entire field of medicine in a methodical manner. The teaching program was practical, and
simple. The teachers were in their 40s and
they all had extensive experience. There
was a large reservoir of other physicians waiting to take their place so that the competition was fierce and the standards
high.
Again, we walked the
wards in pairs of students, choosing patients who had classical stories or
physical signs. Each member of the pair
would catechize his partner. At night,
we would study the textbooks and complement our knowledge. In a short time I became an intelligent
student and had acquired a fundamental basis of medical knowledge. When I
consider this period in retrospect I marvel how a malleable young student's
mind can absorb, understand and remember so much information.
We interacted with
our tutors who provided real personal examples and good mentoring. There was always time for questions and
personal dialogue. It was medical school
education at its best.
We learned obstetrics
and spent 3 months in residence in the maternity hospitals. We lived in the hospital so that we were on
24-hour call and available to observe and treat the patients. We worked in
small groups with only 4 – 6 students in a group. The registrars were very helpful
and enthusiastic and we really received individual teaching. The
maternity hospitals were very busy and we acquired extensive practical
experience. The work was an revelation. The patient would be admitted with
frequent recurring lower abdominal pain. We would examine her and then monitor
the pain, her response and check the foetus. As the pains became more frequent
we would measure the opening of the mouth of the womb, and then when fully
dilated help her to deliver the baby. Many of the patients were complex with malpositions
of the baby, and these had to be corrected. The drama of the baby's arrival,
the delivery of the placenta, the careful anticipation of bleeding of the bare
uterine wall and the prevention of subsequent infection added tension to the
unfolding drama. The care was meticulous and the goal was a healthy well
developed baby and mother. The surroundings were unique: the mother and her attendants,
the sterile labour ward, the smell of the antisepsis, the baby covered in amniotic
fluid, the blood and even the placenta contributed to the deeply emotional
medical environment. I was completely at home with these new experiences, and
later in Rhodesia found great satisfaction with the deliveries. These were
sometimes marred by complications: the feet were in the wrong direction, the
head was malrotated, the uterine contractions were sluggish, the mouth of the
uterus would not open, or the placenta would not separate. The residents were
experienced and these problems were overcome and treated. This was free medicine
at it's best. The physicians their small salaries and treatment and
hospitalization was free. Hadassah could learn much from this free social
system.
The fifth year
comprised surgery, gynecology, pediatrics and the surgical specialties. Again the teaching was dogmatic but we
learned the simple basic principles which I have never forgotten. Prof. Jannie Louw, head of surgery, was a
short, energetic, cutting surgeon. He
hated "scratching" in the patient's body and every movement on the
operating table was perfectly coordinated.
I made a point of assisting him on Tuesday and Friday mornings and would
scrub for hours. He was an expert at
gastrectomy and other complex abdominal operations. Every operation followed the same precise
pattern and it was easy to learn from him.
He was meticulous in post operative patient care and I would follow him
around the wards. On Friday nights he
would be the emergency duty surgeon and since there was much physical violence
and trauma, I learned how to deal with simple life threatening emergencies. He
would operate on the perforated ulcers, intestinal obstructions and ruptured
aortic aneurysms. I spent most of my days and nights in the hospital and would
rise at 5 in the morning to study the textbooks. James Louw, the head of
gynaecology was another meticulous surgeon and with 7-8 expert movements would
perform a hysterectomy in under an hour. He had large hands, and seemed to work
slowly, but each step was deliberate and accurate, that one rarely saw any
bleeding. He would close the abdomen himself and maintained that the patient only
saw and remembered the final abdominal scar.
Since Jill and I
worked and studied together at night, I would often take her home and spent the
night in her parents' home.
Her father, Ivan
Waynik, was the busiest and most respected general practitioner in Sea
Point. He taught me a great deal about
treating people as sick human beings and not as impersonal diseases. He charged a variable fee depending on the patient's
income but if the patient was totally indigent, there was no fee: instead he would
give him the shilling for the bus trip home.
He was up early and out of the house before 5 a.m. He persuaded the
surgeons to operate on his patients in the very early morning so that he could
act as the assistant and see the pathology first hand. He would make his first house calls on
patients before morning surgery at 9 a.m. and would visit patients again at
lunch time and after evening surgery, often not returning home until 10
p.m. We spent many hours together
discussing medical problems and new treatments.
My other friend was a
co-student, Lionel Opie, who was 2 years my senior, and he would show me
interesting patients and explain the pathophysiology of the diseases. Later he
was awarded a Rhodes Scholarship and went off to Oxford to study cardiac
physiology under Krebs, the Noble laureate.
I had many
extracurricular activities. I ran the
Medical School Council and we had a large outreach clinic in the colored area
of Elsies River. Jill and I, with a bevy
of students would spend the evening examining the ill, indigent patients under
the supervision of volunteer doctors and prescribed and dispensed the relevant
treatment. This free medical care was a
great boon to the little town. Sicker
patients were referred to the out-patient clinics at the hospital. The hospital also provided free medical care
to those who had a minimum income. We
learned how to respect patients and understood that free medical care was in no
way inferior to private practice. This
is another basic tenet that has guided my own practice of medicine.
I moved into top gear
in my final year. The volume of
knowledge that we were expected to understand and remember was infinite. We worked hard, walking the wards,
interrogating and examining the patients and studying the books. It was all done in pairs—and I was never
"a lone wolf" .
I graduated at the
top of the class.
I was now a proud
fully fledged doctor, and my mother would introduce me as "My son the
doctor."
Unfortunately, my
relationship with Jill waned and she went to Salisbury where she met a young
general practitioner who returned with her to Cape Town to help and eventually
inherit her father's practice. The newlywed
couple have lived a very happy life together and raised 5 lovely children. The separation, for me, was a serious
psychological blow.
1952 was the year of
my internship. The young
"22-year-old spring chicken" started working at Groote Schuur
Hospital. My first 6 months was served in
surgery with Jannie Louw, the chief of general surgery. I had planned a career in surgery and I was
very happy working for this "tough trooper". He ran a tight ship and was a full time
university surgeon without private practice.
He would tackle the most difficult operations and looked down on his
colleagues in the private sector. He was
superb at gastrectomies and thyroidectomies and could remove a gall bladder in
an hour. The work was meticulous, the operating table was neat and clean and
every operation a planned procedure.
The internship was a
fine educational experience. I lived in the hospital and worked very hard.
Surgery became the centre of my life. Diagnosis was simple and direct and
surgery often curative. The smell of the operating room and the anaesthetics:
scrubbing, gowning and donning the gloves in the operating room and the exhiliration
of opening and repairing the human tissues became part of my daily life. This
was the reason that I opted later for invasive cardiology. Bobby Forsythe,
another fine and forceful senior surgeon with a mop of white hair, deeply
involved in private practice, made a very interesting prophecy: he predicted
that organ transplantation was the future and that I should take off time to
learn immunology.
The second half of
the year was devoted to Internal Medicine under Prof. Frank Forman. I was not
built for the process of diffuse differential diagnosis which was in sharp
contrast to the precision of the surgeons. The physicians were excellent, the
patients very sick and the junior physicians patient and would spend time with
me explaining the reasons for diagnosis and management. We were a happy group
of Jewish interns and became close friends. We deputized for each other and
would help on the other wards when the co-interns were overwhelmed with work.
I would have
continued a career in surgery but 3 months after I started my internship, my
father died suddenly in Hermanus.
This was another major
psychological blow. He had suffered from
severe angina pectoris and was limited in his exercise capacity. He was an
obstinate man and although I booked appointments for him with the senior
physicians in Cape Town he never kept the appointments. He woke up one night
and passed away suddenly from a cardiac arrest. I was unprepared for his sudden
demise. My main pillar of support had been extinguished. The Chevra Kadisha
arrived in Hermanus, our small village, where we lived with short trousers,
sandals and open necked shirts, in top hats and striped morning suits and
without any compassion buried my father.
The shock of the death and the burial caused a deep emotional schism
between myself and my maker. My father
left behind my sick mother, Gloria, my 16-years-old sister who was ready for
university education and Arnold, my 9-year-old brother. Our house still had the same 1600 pound
mortgage which my father had taken in 1942 and been unable to redeem. My mother
had a pension of 40 pounds a month which never increased to cover
inflation. The remainder of the year was
difficult, and it became apparent that my mother was unable to continue with
her little gift shop. She sold the house
in Hermanus and moved to Sea Point, a coastal suburb of Cape Town with
Arnold.
I looked around for
an assistanceship in Cape Town but the salaries were very low. Frankie Forman
suggested that I move northwards to Rhodesia and recommended that I join Ray
Mossop in Gatoooma. He was offering 150 pounds a month plus a furnished house.
I accepted it gracefully.
I sent Gloria to
university, but she was unable to concentrate on studies and left with me for
Rhodesia.
I closed the happiest
period of my care free life.